luulinh90s/Tabular-LLM-Study-Debugging

1<html><head>2<style>3body { font-family: Arial, sans-serif; margin: 20px; }4h1 { text-align: center; }5.cot-title { color: blue; }6.pos-title { color: green; }7h2 { color: black; text-align: left; }8h3 { color: black; text-align: left; }9h4 { color: darkslategray; }10table { width: 100%; border-collapse: collapse; margin: 20px 0; }11table, th, td { border: 1px solid #ddd; padding: 8px; }12th { background-color: #f2f2f2; }13tr:nth-child(even) { background-color: #f9f9f9; }14.highlight { background-color: #ffffcc; }15.true { color: green; }16.false { color: red; }17.highlighted-cell { background-color: yellow; cursor: pointer; }18.step-title { background-color: #f1f1f1; color: #444; padding: 10px; margin: 10px 0; font-size: 18px; border-left: 4px solid #888; }19.step { display: block; }20</style>21</head><body>22<hr>23<h3><span>Statement:</span> ngc 2082 redshift faster than ngc 1705 by 551 kilometers per second plus or minus 6 kilometers per second</h3>24<h3>Input Table: dorado group</h3>25<div class="step">26<div class="step">27<div class="step-title">Step 1: f_add_column(redshift value)</div>28<div id="step-1" class="content">29<table>30<tr>31<td>name</td>32<td>type</td>33<td>ra ( j2000 )</td>34<td>dec ( j2000 )</td>35<td>redshift (km / s )</td>36<td>apparent magnitude</td>37</tr>38<tr>39<td>ngc 2082</td>40<td>sab (rs + ) c</td>41<td>05h41 m51.1s</td>42<td> degree18′04″</td>43<td>1184 ± 6</td>44<td>12.6</td>45</tr>46<tr>47<td>ngc 1947</td>48<td>s0 - pec</td>49<td>05h26 m47.6s</td>50<td> degree45′36″</td>51<td>1100 ± 24</td>52<td>11.7</td>53</tr>54<tr>55<td>ngc 1796</td>56<td>(r) sb (r) dm :</td>57<td>05h02 m42.5s</td>58<td> degree08′24″</td>59<td>1014 ± 9</td>60<td>12.9</td>61</tr>62<tr>63<td>ngc 1688</td>64<td>sb (rs) dm</td>65<td>04h48 m23.8s</td>66<td> degree48′01″</td>67<td>1228 ± 6</td>68<td>12.6</td>69</tr>70<tr>71<td>ngc 1672</td>72<td>(r'_1: ) sb (r) bc sy2</td>73<td>04h45 m42.5s</td>74<td> degree14′50″</td>75<td>1331 ± 3</td>76<td>10.3</td>77</tr>78<tr>79<td>ic 2056</td>80<td>sab (r) b</td>81<td>04h16 m24.5s</td>82<td> degree12′25″</td>83<td>1133 ± 10</td>84<td>12.5</td>85</tr>86<tr>87<td>ngc 1559</td>88<td>sb (s) cd</td>89<td>04h17 m35.8s</td>90<td> degree47′01″</td>91<td>1304 ± 4</td>92<td>11.0</td>93</tr>94<tr>95<td>ngc 1543</td>96<td>(r) sb (l) 0 0</td>97<td>04h12 m43.2s</td>98<td> degree44′17″</td>99<td>1176 ± 7</td>100<td>11.5</td>101</tr>102<tr>103<td>ngc 1574</td>104<td>sa0 -</td>105<td>04h21 m58.8s</td>106<td> degree58′29″</td>107<td>1050 ± 25</td>108<td>11.4</td>109</tr>110<tr>111<td>ngc 1533</td>112<td>(l) sb (rs) 0 0</td>113<td>04h09 m51.8s</td>114<td> degree07′06″</td>115<td>790 ± 5</td>116<td>11.7</td>117</tr>118<tr>119<td>ngc 1546</td>120<td>sa0 +</td>121<td>04h14 m36.5s</td>122<td> degree03′39″</td>123<td>1284 ± 14</td>124<td>11.8</td>125</tr>126<tr>127<td>ngc 1553</td>128<td>sa (rl) 0 0</td>129<td>04h16 m10.5s</td>130<td> degree46′49″</td>131<td>1080 ± 11</td>132<td>10.3</td>133</tr>134<tr>135<td>ngc 1549</td>136<td>e0 1</td>137<td>04h15 m45.1s</td>138<td> degree35′32″</td>139<td>1220 ± 15</td>140<td>10.7</td>141</tr>142<tr>143<td>ngc 1566</td>144<td>(r'_1) sab (rs) bcsy1</td>145<td>04h20 m00.4s</td>146<td> degree56′16″</td>147<td>1504 ± 2</td>148<td>10.3</td>149</tr>150<tr>151<td>ngc 1617</td>152<td>(r') sab (rs) a</td>153<td>04h31 m39.5s</td>154<td> degree36′08″</td>155<td>1063 ± 21</td>156<td>11.4</td>157</tr>158<tr>159<td>ngc 1515</td>160<td>sab (s) bc</td>161<td>04h04 m02.7s</td>162<td> degree06′00″</td>163<td>1175 ± 7</td>164<td>12.1</td>165</tr>166<tr>167<td>ngc 1705</td>168<td>sa0 - pec</td>169<td>04h54 m13.5s</td>170<td> degree21′40″</td>171<td>633 ± 6</td>172<td>12.8</td>173</tr>174<tr>175<td>ngc 1596</td>176<td>sa0: sp</td>177<td>04h27 m38.1s</td>178<td> degree01′40″</td>179<td>1510 ± 8</td>180<td>12.1</td>181</tr>182</table>183</div>184<hr>185<div class="step">186<div class="step-title">Step 2: f_select_row(row 0, row 16)</div>187<div id="step-0" class="content">188<table>189<tr>190<td>name</td>191<td>type</td>192<td>ra ( j2000 )</td>193<td>dec ( j2000 )</td>194<td>redshift (km / s )</td>195<td>apparent magnitude</td>196<td>redshift value</td>197</tr>198<tr>199<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">ngc 2082</span></td>200<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">sab (rs + ) c</span></td>201<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">05h41 m51.1s</span></td>202<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation"> degree18′04″</span></td>203<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">1184 ± 6</span></td>204<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">12.6</span></td>205<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">1184</span></td>206</tr>207<tr>208<td>ngc 1947</td>209<td>s0 - pec</td>210<td>05h26 m47.6s</td>211<td> degree45′36″</td>212<td>1100 ± 24</td>213<td>11.7</td>214<td>1100</td>215</tr>216<tr>217<td>ngc 1796</td>218<td>(r) sb (r) dm :</td>219<td>05h02 m42.5s</td>220<td> degree08′24″</td>221<td>1014 ± 9</td>222<td>12.9</td>223<td>1014</td>224</tr>225<tr>226<td>ngc 1688</td>227<td>sb (rs) dm</td>228<td>04h48 m23.8s</td>229<td> degree48′01″</td>230<td>1228 ± 6</td>231<td>12.6</td>232<td>1228</td>233</tr>234<tr>235<td>ngc 1672</td>236<td>(r'_1: ) sb (r) bc sy2</td>237<td>04h45 m42.5s</td>238<td> degree14′50″</td>239<td>1331 ± 3</td>240<td>10.3</td>241<td>1331</td>242</tr>243<tr>244<td>ic 2056</td>245<td>sab (r) b</td>246<td>04h16 m24.5s</td>247<td> degree12′25″</td>248<td>1133 ± 10</td>249<td>12.5</td>250<td>1133</td>251</tr>252<tr>253<td>ngc 1559</td>254<td>sb (s) cd</td>255<td>04h17 m35.8s</td>256<td> degree47′01″</td>257<td>1304 ± 4</td>258<td>11.0</td>259<td>1304</td>260</tr>261<tr>262<td>ngc 1543</td>263<td>(r) sb (l) 0 0</td>264<td>04h12 m43.2s</td>265<td> degree44′17″</td>266<td>1176 ± 7</td>267<td>11.5</td>268<td>1176</td>269</tr>270<tr>271<td>ngc 1574</td>272<td>sa0 -</td>273<td>04h21 m58.8s</td>274<td> degree58′29″</td>275<td>1050 ± 25</td>276<td>11.4</td>277<td>1050</td>278</tr>279<tr>280<td>ngc 1533</td>281<td>(l) sb (rs) 0 0</td>282<td>04h09 m51.8s</td>283<td> degree07′06″</td>284<td>790 ± 5</td>285<td>11.7</td>286<td>790</td>287</tr>288<tr>289<td>ngc 1546</td>290<td>sa0 +</td>291<td>04h14 m36.5s</td>292<td> degree03′39″</td>293<td>1284 ± 14</td>294<td>11.8</td>295<td>1284</td>296</tr>297<tr>298<td>ngc 1553</td>299<td>sa (rl) 0 0</td>300<td>04h16 m10.5s</td>301<td> degree46′49″</td>302<td>1080 ± 11</td>303<td>10.3</td>304<td>1080</td>305</tr>306<tr>307<td>ngc 1549</td>308<td>e0 1</td>309<td>04h15 m45.1s</td>310<td> degree35′32″</td>311<td>1220 ± 15</td>312<td>10.7</td>313<td>1220</td>314</tr>315<tr>316<td>ngc 1566</td>317<td>(r'_1) sab (rs) bcsy1</td>318<td>04h20 m00.4s</td>319<td> degree56′16″</td>320<td>1504 ± 2</td>321<td>10.3</td>322<td>1504</td>323</tr>324<tr>325<td>ngc 1617</td>326<td>(r') sab (rs) a</td>327<td>04h31 m39.5s</td>328<td> degree36′08″</td>329<td>1063 ± 21</td>330<td>11.4</td>331<td>1063</td>332</tr>333<tr>334<td>ngc 1515</td>335<td>sab (s) bc</td>336<td>04h04 m02.7s</td>337<td> degree06′00″</td>338<td>1175 ± 7</td>339<td>12.1</td>340<td>1175</td>341</tr>342<tr>343<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">ngc 1705</span></td>344<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">sa0 - pec</span></td>345<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">04h54 m13.5s</span></td>346<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation"> degree21′40″</span></td>347<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">633 ± 6</span></td>348<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">12.8</span></td>349<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">633</span></td>350</tr>351<tr>352<td>ngc 1596</td>353<td>sa0: sp</td>354<td>04h27 m38.1s</td>355<td> degree01′40″</td>356<td>1510 ± 8</td>357<td>12.1</td>358<td>1510</td>359</tr>360</table>361</div>362</div>363<hr>364<div class="step">365<div class="step-title">Step 3: f_select_column(name)</div>366<div id="step-1" class="content">367<table>368<tr>369<td>name</td>370<td>type</td>371<td>ra ( j2000 )</td>372<td>dec ( j2000 )</td>373<td>redshift (km / s )</td>374<td>apparent magnitude</td>375<td>redshift value</td>376</tr>377<tr>378<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">ngc 2082</span></td>379<td>sab (rs + ) c</td>380<td>05h41 m51.1s</td>381<td> degree18′04″</td>382<td>1184 ± 6</td>383<td>12.6</td>384<td>1184</td>385</tr>386<tr>387<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">ngc 1705</span></td>388<td>sa0 - pec</td>389<td>04h54 m13.5s</td>390<td> degree21′40″</td>391<td>633 ± 6</td>392<td>12.8</td>393<td>633</td>394</tr>395</table>396</div>397</div>398<hr>399<div class="step">400<div class="step-title">Step 4: simple_query()</div>401<div id="step-2" class="content">402<table>403<tr>404<td>name</td>405</tr>406<tr>407<td>ngc 2082</td>408</tr>409<tr>410<td>ngc 1705</td>411</tr>412</table>413</div>414</div>415<hr>416<h2>Prompting LLM for the final answer... >>> </h2>417</div>418</div>419<hr>420<h3>Prediction:</span> FALSE</h3>421</body></html>422