luulinh90s/Tabular-LLM-Study-Debugging

1<html><head>2<style>3body { font-family: Arial, sans-serif; margin: 20px; }4h1 { text-align: center; }5.cot-title { color: blue; }6.pos-title { color: green; }7h2 { color: black; text-align: left; }8h3 { color: black; text-align: left; }9h4 { color: darkslategray; }10table { width: 100%; border-collapse: collapse; margin: 20px 0; }11table, th, td { border: 1px solid #ddd; padding: 8px; }12th { background-color: #f2f2f2; }13tr:nth-child(even) { background-color: #f9f9f9; }14.highlight { background-color: #ffffcc; }15.true { color: green; }16.false { color: red; }17.highlighted-cell { background-color: yellow; cursor: pointer; }18.step-title { background-color: #f1f1f1; color: #444; padding: 10px; margin: 10px 0; font-size: 18px; border-left: 4px solid #888; }19.step { display: block; }20</style>21</head><body>22<hr>23<h3><span>Statement:</span> three of the total games featured had an attendance in the 3000s</h3>24<h3>Input Table: 2008 - 09 bradford city a.f.c. season</h3>25<div class="step">26<div class="step">27<div class="step-title">Step 1: f_add_column(year)</div>28<div id="step-1" class="content">29<table>30<tr>31<td>game</td>32<td>date</td>33<td>opponent</td>34<td>venue</td>35<td>result</td>36<td>attendance</td>37</tr>38<tr>39<td>1</td>40<td>9 august 2008</td>41<td>notts county</td>42<td>home</td>43<td>2 - 1</td>44<td>14038</td>45</tr>46<tr>47<td>2</td>48<td>16 august 2008</td>49<td>macclesfield town</td>50<td>away</td>51<td>2 - 0</td>52<td>2556</td>53</tr>54<tr>55<td>3</td>56<td>23 august 2008</td>57<td>rochdale</td>58<td>home</td>59<td>2 - 0</td>60<td>13154</td>61</tr>62<tr>63<td>4</td>64<td>30 august 2008</td>65<td>aldershot town</td>66<td>away</td>67<td>2 - 3</td>68<td>3805</td>69</tr>70<tr>71<td>5</td>72<td>6 september 2008</td>73<td>port vale</td>74<td>away</td>75<td>2 - 0</td>76<td>7273</td>77</tr>78<tr>79<td>6</td>80<td>13 september 2008</td>81<td>exeter city</td>82<td>home</td>83<td>4 - 1</td>84<td>12683</td>85</tr>86<tr>87<td>7</td>88<td>20 september 2008</td>89<td>bournemouth</td>90<td>home</td>91<td>1 - 3</td>92<td>12824</td>93</tr>94<tr>95<td>8</td>96<td>27 september 2008</td>97<td>shrewsbury town</td>98<td>away</td>99<td>0 - 2</td>100<td>6517</td>101</tr>102<tr>103<td>9</td>104<td>4 october 2008</td>105<td>luton town</td>106<td>home</td>107<td>1 - 1</td>108<td>13083</td>109</tr>110<tr>111<td>10</td>112<td>11 october 2008</td>113<td>accrington stanley</td>114<td>away</td>115<td>3 - 2</td>116<td>3012</td>117</tr>118<tr>119<td>11</td>120<td>18 october 2008</td>121<td>gillingham</td>122<td>home</td>123<td>2 - 2</td>124<td>12432</td>125</tr>126<tr>127<td>12</td>128<td>21 october 2008</td>129<td>darlington</td>130<td>away</td>131<td>1 - 2</td>132<td>3034</td>133</tr>134<tr>135<td>13</td>136<td>24 october 2008</td>137<td>grimsby town</td>138<td>away</td>139<td>3 - 1</td>140<td>4470</td>141</tr>142<tr>143<td>14</td>144<td>28 october 2008</td>145<td>bury</td>146<td>home</td>147<td>1 - 0</td>148<td>12830</td>149</tr>150<tr>151<td>15</td>152<td>1 november 2008</td>153<td>barnet</td>154<td>home</td>155<td>3 - 3</td>156<td>12510</td>157</tr>158<tr>159<td>16</td>160<td>15 november 2008</td>161<td>wycombe wanderers</td>162<td>away</td>163<td>0 - 1</td>164<td>5002</td>165</tr>166<tr>167<td>17</td>168<td>22 november 2008</td>169<td>rotherham united</td>170<td>away</td>171<td>2 - 0</td>172<td>4586</td>173</tr>174<tr>175<td>18</td>176<td>25 november 2008</td>177<td>chesterfield</td>178<td>home</td>179<td>3 - 2</td>180<td>12145</td>181</tr>182<tr>183<td>19</td>184<td>6 december 2008</td>185<td>dagenham & redbridge</td>186<td>home</td>187<td>1 - 1</td>188<td>12145</td>189</tr>190<tr>191<td>20</td>192<td>13 december 2008</td>193<td>brentford</td>194<td>away</td>195<td>1 - 2</td>196<td>4339</td>197</tr>198<tr>199<td>21</td>200<td>20 december 2008</td>201<td>chester city</td>202<td>home</td>203<td>0 - 0</td>204<td>12092</td>205</tr>206<tr>207<td>22</td>208<td>26 december 2008</td>209<td>lincoln city</td>210<td>away</td>211<td>0 - 0</td>212<td>6156</td>213</tr>214<tr>215<td>23</td>216<td>28 december 2008</td>217<td>morecambe</td>218<td>home</td>219<td>4 - 0</td>220<td>13105</td>221</tr>222<tr>223<td>24</td>224<td>3 january 2009</td>225<td>shrewsbury town</td>226<td>home</td>227<td>0 - 0</td>228<td>12877</td>229</tr>230<tr>231<td>25</td>232<td>17 january 2009</td>233<td>accrington stanley</td>234<td>home</td>235<td>1 - 1</td>236<td>12172</td>237</tr>238<tr>239<td>26</td>240<td>24 january 2009</td>241<td>luton town</td>242<td>away</td>243<td>3 - 3</td>244<td>6053</td>245</tr>246<tr>247<td>27</td>248<td>27 january 2009</td>249<td>bury</td>250<td>away</td>251<td>0 - 1</td>252<td>4112</td>253</tr>254<tr>255<td>28</td>256<td>31 january 2009</td>257<td>grimsby town</td>258<td>home</td>259<td>2 - 0</td>260<td>12816</td>261</tr>262<tr>263<td>29</td>264<td>7 february 2009</td>265<td>gillingham</td>266<td>away</td>267<td>2 - 0</td>268<td>4866</td>269</tr>270<tr>271<td>30</td>272<td>14 february 2009</td>273<td>wycombe wanderers</td>274<td>home</td>275<td>1 - 0</td>276<td>12689</td>277</tr>278<tr>279<td>31</td>280<td>17 february 2009</td>281<td>darlington</td>282<td>home</td>283<td>0 - 0</td>284<td>12782</td>285</tr>286<tr>287<td>32</td>288<td>21 february 2009</td>289<td>barnet</td>290<td>away</td>291<td>1 - 4</td>292<td>2445</td>293</tr>294<tr>295<td>33</td>296<td>28 february 2009</td>297<td>notts county</td>298<td>away</td>299<td>1 - 3</td>300<td>5138</td>301</tr>302<tr>303<td>34</td>304<td>3 march 2009</td>305<td>macclesfield town</td>306<td>home</td>307<td>1 - 0</td>308<td>11908</td>309</tr>310<tr>311<td>35</td>312<td>7 march 2009</td>313<td>aldershot town</td>314<td>home</td>315<td>5 - 0</td>316<td>12465</td>317</tr>318<tr>319<td>36</td>320<td>10 march 2009</td>321<td>rochdale</td>322<td>away</td>323<td>0 - 3</td>324<td>5157</td>325</tr>326<tr>327<td>37</td>328<td>14 march 2009</td>329<td>exeter city</td>330<td>away</td>331<td>0 - 1</td>332<td>5253</td>333</tr>334<tr>335<td>38</td>336<td>17 march 2009</td>337<td>bournemouth</td>338<td>away</td>339<td>1 - 4</td>340<td>4847</td>341</tr>342<tr>343<td>39</td>344<td>21 march 2009</td>345<td>port vale</td>346<td>home</td>347<td>0 - 1</td>348<td>12436</td>349</tr>350<tr>351<td>40</td>352<td>28 march 2009</td>353<td>chester city</td>354<td>away</td>355<td>0 - 0</td>356<td>2735</td>357</tr>358<tr>359<td>41</td>360<td>4 april 2009</td>361<td>brentford</td>362<td>home</td>363<td>1 - 1</td>364<td>12832</td>365</tr>366<tr>367<td>42</td>368<td>10 april 2009</td>369<td>morecambe</td>370<td>away</td>371<td>1 - 2</td>372<td>4546</td>373</tr>374<tr>375<td>43</td>376<td>13 april 2009</td>377<td>lincoln city</td>378<td>home</td>379<td>1 - 1</td>380<td>12932</td>381</tr>382</table>383</div>384<hr>385<div class="step">386<div class="step-title">Step 2: f_select_row(row 3, row 7, row 9, row 11)</div>387<div id="step-0" class="content">388<table>389<tr>390<td>game</td>391<td>date</td>392<td>opponent</td>393<td>venue</td>394<td>result</td>395<td>attendance</td>396<td>year</td>397</tr>398<tr>399<td>1</td>400<td>9 august 2008</td>401<td>notts county</td>402<td>home</td>403<td>2 - 1</td>404<td>14038</td>405<td>2008</td>406</tr>407<tr>408<td>2</td>409<td>16 august 2008</td>410<td>macclesfield town</td>411<td>away</td>412<td>2 - 0</td>413<td>2556</td>414<td>2008</td>415</tr>416<tr>417<td>3</td>418<td>23 august 2008</td>419<td>rochdale</td>420<td>home</td>421<td>2 - 0</td>422<td>13154</td>423<td>2008</td>424</tr>425<tr>426<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">4</span></td>427<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">30 august 2008</span></td>428<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">aldershot town</span></td>429<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">away</span></td>430<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">2 - 3</span></td>431<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">3805</span></td>432<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">2008</span></td>433</tr>434<tr>435<td>5</td>436<td>6 september 2008</td>437<td>port vale</td>438<td>away</td>439<td>2 - 0</td>440<td>7273</td>441<td>2008</td>442</tr>443<tr>444<td>6</td>445<td>13 september 2008</td>446<td>exeter city</td>447<td>home</td>448<td>4 - 1</td>449<td>12683</td>450<td>2008</td>451</tr>452<tr>453<td>7</td>454<td>20 september 2008</td>455<td>bournemouth</td>456<td>home</td>457<td>1 - 3</td>458<td>12824</td>459<td>2008</td>460</tr>461<tr>462<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">8</span></td>463<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">27 september 2008</span></td>464<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">shrewsbury town</span></td>465<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">away</span></td>466<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">0 - 2</span></td>467<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">6517</span></td>468<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">2008</span></td>469</tr>470<tr>471<td>9</td>472<td>4 october 2008</td>473<td>luton town</td>474<td>home</td>475<td>1 - 1</td>476<td>13083</td>477<td>2008</td>478</tr>479<tr>480<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">10</span></td>481<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">11 october 2008</span></td>482<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">accrington stanley</span></td>483<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">away</span></td>484<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">3 - 2</span></td>485<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">3012</span></td>486<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">2008</span></td>487</tr>488<tr>489<td>11</td>490<td>18 october 2008</td>491<td>gillingham</td>492<td>home</td>493<td>2 - 2</td>494<td>12432</td>495<td>2008</td>496</tr>497<tr>498<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">12</span></td>499<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">21 october 2008</span></td>500<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">darlington</span></td>501<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">away</span></td>502<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">1 - 2</span></td>503<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">3034</span></td>504<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">2008</span></td>505</tr>506<tr>507<td>13</td>508<td>24 october 2008</td>509<td>grimsby town</td>510<td>away</td>511<td>3 - 1</td>512<td>4470</td>513<td>2008</td>514</tr>515<tr>516<td>14</td>517<td>28 october 2008</td>518<td>bury</td>519<td>home</td>520<td>1 - 0</td>521<td>12830</td>522<td>2008</td>523</tr>524<tr>525<td>15</td>526<td>1 november 2008</td>527<td>barnet</td>528<td>home</td>529<td>3 - 3</td>530<td>12510</td>531<td>2008</td>532</tr>533<tr>534<td>16</td>535<td>15 november 2008</td>536<td>wycombe wanderers</td>537<td>away</td>538<td>0 - 1</td>539<td>5002</td>540<td>2008</td>541</tr>542<tr>543<td>17</td>544<td>22 november 2008</td>545<td>rotherham united</td>546<td>away</td>547<td>2 - 0</td>548<td>4586</td>549<td>2008</td>550</tr>551<tr>552<td>18</td>553<td>25 november 2008</td>554<td>chesterfield</td>555<td>home</td>556<td>3 - 2</td>557<td>12145</td>558<td>2008</td>559</tr>560<tr>561<td>19</td>562<td>6 december 2008</td>563<td>dagenham & redbridge</td>564<td>home</td>565<td>1 - 1</td>566<td>12145</td>567<td>2008</td>568</tr>569<tr>570<td>20</td>571<td>13 december 2008</td>572<td>brentford</td>573<td>away</td>574<td>1 - 2</td>575<td>4339</td>576<td>2008</td>577</tr>578<tr>579<td>21</td>580<td>20 december 2008</td>581<td>chester city</td>582<td>home</td>583<td>0 - 0</td>584<td>12092</td>585<td>2008</td>586</tr>587<tr>588<td>22</td>589<td>26 december 2008</td>590<td>lincoln city</td>591<td>away</td>592<td>0 - 0</td>593<td>6156</td>594<td>2008</td>595</tr>596<tr>597<td>23</td>598<td>28 december 2008</td>599<td>morecambe</td>600<td>home</td>601<td>4 - 0</td>602<td>13105</td>603<td>2008</td>604</tr>605<tr>606<td>24</td>607<td>3 january 2009</td>608<td>shrewsbury town</td>609<td>home</td>610<td>0 - 0</td>611<td>12877</td>612<td>2009</td>613</tr>614<tr>615<td>25</td>616<td>17 january 2009</td>617<td>accrington stanley</td>618<td>home</td>619<td>1 - 1</td>620<td>12172</td>621<td>2009</td>622</tr>623<tr>624<td>26</td>625<td>24 january 2009</td>626<td>luton town</td>627<td>away</td>628<td>3 - 3</td>629<td>6053</td>630<td>2009</td>631</tr>632<tr>633<td>27</td>634<td>27 january 2009</td>635<td>bury</td>636<td>away</td>637<td>0 - 1</td>638<td>4112</td>639<td>2009</td>640</tr>641<tr>642<td>28</td>643<td>31 january 2009</td>644<td>grimsby town</td>645<td>home</td>646<td>2 - 0</td>647<td>12816</td>648<td>2009</td>649</tr>650<tr>651<td>29</td>652<td>7 february 2009</td>653<td>gillingham</td>654<td>away</td>655<td>2 - 0</td>656<td>4866</td>657<td>2009</td>658</tr>659<tr>660<td>30</td>661<td>14 february 2009</td>662<td>wycombe wanderers</td>663<td>home</td>664<td>1 - 0</td>665<td>12689</td>666<td>2009</td>667</tr>668<tr>669<td>31</td>670<td>17 february 2009</td>671<td>darlington</td>672<td>home</td>673<td>0 - 0</td>674<td>12782</td>675<td>2009</td>676</tr>677<tr>678<td>32</td>679<td>21 february 2009</td>680<td>barnet</td>681<td>away</td>682<td>1 - 4</td>683<td>2445</td>684<td>2009</td>685</tr>686<tr>687<td>33</td>688<td>28 february 2009</td>689<td>notts county</td>690<td>away</td>691<td>1 - 3</td>692<td>5138</td>693<td>2009</td>694</tr>695<tr>696<td>34</td>697<td>3 march 2009</td>698<td>macclesfield town</td>699<td>home</td>700<td>1 - 0</td>701<td>11908</td>702<td>2009</td>703</tr>704<tr>705<td>35</td>706<td>7 march 2009</td>707<td>aldershot town</td>708<td>home</td>709<td>5 - 0</td>710<td>12465</td>711<td>2009</td>712</tr>713<tr>714<td>36</td>715<td>10 march 2009</td>716<td>rochdale</td>717<td>away</td>718<td>0 - 3</td>719<td>5157</td>720<td>2009</td>721</tr>722<tr>723<td>37</td>724<td>14 march 2009</td>725<td>exeter city</td>726<td>away</td>727<td>0 - 1</td>728<td>5253</td>729<td>2009</td>730</tr>731<tr>732<td>38</td>733<td>17 march 2009</td>734<td>bournemouth</td>735<td>away</td>736<td>1 - 4</td>737<td>4847</td>738<td>2009</td>739</tr>740<tr>741<td>39</td>742<td>21 march 2009</td>743<td>port vale</td>744<td>home</td>745<td>0 - 1</td>746<td>12436</td>747<td>2009</td>748</tr>749<tr>750<td>40</td>751<td>28 march 2009</td>752<td>chester city</td>753<td>away</td>754<td>0 - 0</td>755<td>2735</td>756<td>2009</td>757</tr>758<tr>759<td>41</td>760<td>4 april 2009</td>761<td>brentford</td>762<td>home</td>763<td>1 - 1</td>764<td>12832</td>765<td>2009</td>766</tr>767<tr>768<td>42</td>769<td>10 april 2009</td>770<td>morecambe</td>771<td>away</td>772<td>1 - 2</td>773<td>4546</td>774<td>2009</td>775</tr>776<tr>777<td>43</td>778<td>13 april 2009</td>779<td>lincoln city</td>780<td>home</td>781<td>1 - 1</td>782<td>12932</td>783<td>2009</td>784</tr>785</table>786</div>787</div>788<hr>789<div class="step">790<div class="step-title">Step 3: f_select_column(game, attendance)</div>791<div id="step-1" class="content">792<table>793<tr>794<td>game</td>795<td>date</td>796<td>opponent</td>797<td>venue</td>798<td>result</td>799<td>attendance</td>800<td>year</td>801</tr>802<tr>803<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">4</span></td>804<td>30 august 2008</td>805<td>aldershot town</td>806<td>away</td>807<td>2 - 3</td>808<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">3805</span></td>809<td>2008</td>810</tr>811<tr>812<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">8</span></td>813<td>27 september 2008</td>814<td>shrewsbury town</td>815<td>away</td>816<td>0 - 2</td>817<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">6517</span></td>818<td>2008</td>819</tr>820<tr>821<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">10</span></td>822<td>11 october 2008</td>823<td>accrington stanley</td>824<td>away</td>825<td>3 - 2</td>826<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">3012</span></td>827<td>2008</td>828</tr>829<tr>830<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">12</span></td>831<td>21 october 2008</td>832<td>darlington</td>833<td>away</td>834<td>1 - 2</td>835<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation">3034</span></td>836<td>2008</td>837</tr>838</table>839</div>840</div>841<hr>842<div class="step">843<div class="step-title">Step 4: simple_query()</div>844<div id="step-2" class="content">845<table>846<tr>847<td>game</td>848<td>attendance</td>849</tr>850<tr>851<td>4</td>852<td>3805</td>853</tr>854<tr>855<td>8</td>856<td>6517</td>857</tr>858<tr>859<td>10</td>860<td>3012</td>861</tr>862<tr>863<td>12</td>864<td>3034</td>865</tr>866</table>867</div>868</div>869<hr>870<h2>Prompting LLM for the final answer... >>> </h2>871</div>872</div>873<hr>874<h3>Prediction:</span> TRUE</h3>875</body></html>876