luulinh90s/Tabular-LLM-Study-Debugging

1<html><head>2<style>3body { font-family: Arial, sans-serif; margin: 20px; }4h1 { text-align: center; }5.cot-title { color: blue; }6.pos-title { color: green; }7h2 { color: black; text-align: left; }8h3 { color: black; text-align: left; }9h4 { color: darkslategray; }10table { width: 100%; border-collapse: collapse; margin: 20px 0; }11table, th, td { border: 1px solid #ddd; padding: 8px; }12th { background-color: #f2f2f2; }13tr:nth-child(even) { background-color: #f9f9f9; }14.highlight { background-color: #ffffcc; }15.true { color: green; }16.false { color: red; }17.highlighted-cell { background-color: yellow; cursor: pointer; }18.step-title { background-color: #f1f1f1; color: #444; padding: 10px; margin: 10px 0; font-size: 18px; border-left: 4px solid #888; }19.step { display: block; }20</style>21</head><body>22<h1 class="pos-title">Plan-of-SQLs (Ours)</h1>23<hr>24<h3><span>Statement:</span> the total brazilian population for ages 15 - 17 is 10357874</h3>25<h3>Ground-truth:</span> TRUE</h3>26<h3>Input Table: none</h3>27<div class="step">28<div class="step">29<div class="step-title">Step 1: Select rows where 'age_group' is '15 - 17'.</div>30<div id="step-1" class="content">31<table>32<tr>33<td>age_group</td>34<td>brazil_100___percent_of_the_population</td>35<td>white_47_73___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>36<td>black_7_61___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>37<td>yellow_1_09___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>38<td>brown__multiracial__43_13___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>39<td>indians_0_43___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>40<td>unspecified_0_0034</td>41</tr>42<tr>43<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">population</span></td>44<td>190 755 799</td>45<td>91 051 646</td>46<td>14 517 961</td>47<td>2 084 288</td>48<td>82 277 333</td>49<td>817 963</td>50<td>6 608</td>51</tr>52<tr>53<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">0 - 4</span></td>54<td>13 796 158 (7 , 23%)</td>55<td>6 701 186 (7 , 36% / 48 , 57%)</td>56<td>655 958 (4 , 52% / 4 , 75%)</td>57<td>119 956 (5 , 76% / 0 , 87%)</td>58<td>6 217 638 (7 , 56% / 45 , 07%)</td>59<td>101 195 (12 , 37% / 0 , 73%)</td>60<td>225</td>61</tr>62<tr>63<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">5 - 9</span></td>64<td>14 969 375 (7 , 85%)</td>65<td>6 562 558 (7 , 21% / 43 , 84%)</td>66<td>887 209 (6 , 11% / 5 , 93%)</td>67<td>139 543 (6 , 69% / 0 , 93%)</td>68<td>7 279 983 (8 , 85% / 48 , 63%)</td>69<td>99 841 (12 , 21% / 0 , 67%)</td>70<td>241</td>71</tr>72<tr>73<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">10 - 14</span></td>74<td>17 166 761 (9 , 00%)</td>75<td>7 196 738 (7 , 90% / 41 , 92%)</td>76<td>1 155 472 (7 , 96% / 6 , 73%)</td>77<td>161 453 (7 , 75% / 0 , 94%)</td>78<td>8 557 952 (10 , 40% / 49 , 85%)</td>79<td>94 826 (11 , 59% / 0 , 55%)</td>80<td>320</td>81</tr>82<tr>83<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">15 - 19</span></td>84<td>16 990 872 (8 , 91%)</td>85<td>7 311 734 (8 , 03% / 43 , 03%)</td>86<td>1 264 183 (8 , 71% / 7 , 44%)</td>87<td>177 008 (8 , 49% / 1 , 04%)</td>88<td>8 155 126 (9.91% / 48.00%)</td>89<td>82 500 (10 , 86% / 0 , 49%)</td>90<td>321</td>91</tr>92<tr>93<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">15 - 17</span></td>94<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">10 357 874</span></td>95<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">4 390 760</span></td>96<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">764 245</span></td>97<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">105 554</span></td>98<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">5 045 778</span></td>99<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">51 367</span></td>100<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">170</span></td>101</tr>102<tr>103<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">18 - 19</span></td>104<td>6 632 998</td>105<td>2 920 974</td>106<td>499 938</td>107<td>71 454</td>108<td>3 109 348</td>109<td>31 133</td>110<td>151</td>111</tr>112<tr>113<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">20 - 24</span></td>114<td>17 245 192 (9 , 04%)</td>115<td>7 774 488 (8 , 54% / 45 , 08%)</td>116<td>1 381 677 (9 , 52% / 8 , 01%)</td>117<td>200 060 (9 , 60% / 1 , 16%)</td>118<td>7 814 487 (9 , 50% / 45 , 31%)</td>119<td>73 387 (8 , 97% / 0 , 43%)</td>120<td>1 093</td>121</tr>122<tr>123<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">25 - 29</span></td>124<td>17 104 414 (8 , 97%)</td>125<td>7 936 115 (8 , 72% / 46 , 40%)</td>126<td>1 443 820 (9 , 95% / 8 , 44%)</td>127<td>202 733 (9 , 73% / 1 , 19%)</td>128<td>7 455 402 (9.06% / 43 , 59%)</td>129<td>65 104 (7 , 96% / 0 , 38%)</td>130<td>1 240</td>131</tr>132<tr>133<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">30 - 34</span></td>134<td>15 744 512 (8 , 25%)</td>135<td>7 344 600 (8 , 07% / 46 , 65%)</td>136<td>1 360 298 (9 , 37% / 8 , 64%)</td>137<td>182 150 (8 , 74% / 1 , 16%)</td>138<td>6 800 175 (8 , 26% / 43 , 19%)</td>139<td>56 326 (6 , 89% / 0 , 36%)</td>140<td>963</td>141</tr>142<tr>143<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">35 - 39</span></td>144<td>13 888 579 (7 , 28%)</td>145<td>6 596 137 (7 , 24% / 47 , 49%)</td>146<td>1 175 333 (8 , 10% / 8 , 46%)</td>147<td>152 546 (7 , 32% / 1 , 10)</td>148<td>5 915 773 (7 , 18% / 42 , 59%)</td>149<td>48 167 (5 , 89% / 0 , 35%)</td>150<td>623</td>151</tr>152<tr>153<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">40 - 44</span></td>154<td>13 009 364 (6 , 82%)</td>155<td>6 365 363 (6 , 99% / 48.93%)</td>156<td>1 095 301 (7 , 54% / 8 , 42%)</td>157<td>139 230 (6 , 68% / 1 , 07%)</td>158<td>5 368 059 (6 , 52% / 41 , 26%)</td>159<td>40 950 (5.01% / 0 , 31%)</td>160<td>461</td>161</tr>162<tr>163<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">45 - 49</span></td>164<td>11 833 352 (6 , 20%)</td>165<td>6 052 769 (6 , 65% / 51 , 15%)</td>166<td>972 738 (6 , 70% / 8 , 22%)</td>167<td>124 664 (5.98% / 1 , 05%)</td>168<td>4 647 205 (5 , 65% / 39 , 27%)</td>169<td>35 645 (4 , 36% / 0 , 30%)</td>170<td>331</td>171</tr>172<tr>173<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">50 - 54</span></td>174<td>10 140 402 (5 , 32%)</td>175<td>5 286 559 (5 , 81% / 52 , 13%)</td>176<td>848 098 (5 , 84% / 8 , 36%)</td>177<td>106 539 (5 , 11% / 1 , 05%)</td>178<td>3 869 792 (4 , 70% / 38 , 16%)</td>179<td>29 156 (3 , 56% / 0 , 29%)</td>180<td>258</td>181</tr>182<tr>183<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">55 - 59</span></td>184<td>8 276 221 (4 , 34%)</td>185<td>4 404 057 (4 , 84% / 53 , 21%)</td>186<td>675 404 (4 , 65% / 8 , 16%)</td>187<td>95 149 (4 , 57% / 1 , 15%)</td>188<td>3 076 630 (3 , 74% / 37 , 17%)</td>189<td>24 800 (3 , 03% / 0 , 30%)</td>190<td>181</td>191</tr>192<tr>193<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">60 - 69</span></td>194<td>11 349 930 (5 , 95%)</td>195<td>6 158 001 (6 , 76% / 54 , 26%)</td>196<td>906 487 (6 , 24% / 7 , 99%)</td>197<td>152 099 (7 , 30% / 1 , 34%)</td>198<td>4 097 068 (4 , 98% / 36 , 10%)</td>199<td>36 062 (4 , 41% / 0 , 32%)</td>200<td>213</td>201</tr>202</table>203</div>204<hr>205<div class="step">206<div class="step-title">Step 2: Extract the numerical population for ages 15 - 17 from the 'brazil_100___percent_of_the_population' column to add column 'population_15_17' to existing table.</div>207<div id="step-0" class="content">208<table>209<tr>210<td>age_group</td>211<td>brazil_100___percent_of_the_population</td>212<td>white_47_73___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>213<td>black_7_61___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>214<td>yellow_1_09___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>215<td>brown__multiracial__43_13___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>216<td>indians_0_43___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>217<td>unspecified_0_0034</td>218</tr>219<tr>220<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">15 - 17</span></td>221<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">10 357 874</span></td>222<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">4 390 760</span></td>223<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">764 245</span></td>224<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">105 554</span></td>225<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">5 045 778</span></td>226<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">51 367</span></td>227<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">170</span></td>228</tr>229</table>230</div>231</div>232<hr>233<div class="step">234<div class="step-title">Step 3: Select rows where 'population_15_17' is 10357874.</div>235<div id="step-1" class="content">236<table>237<tr>238<td>age_group</td>239<td>brazil_100___percent_of_the_population</td>240<td>white_47_73___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>241<td>black_7_61___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>242<td>yellow_1_09___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>243<td>brown__multiracial__43_13___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>244<td>indians_0_43___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>245<td>unspecified_0_0034</td>246<td>population_15_17</td>247</tr>248<tr>249<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">15 - 17</span></td>250<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">10 357 874</span></td>251<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">4 390 760</span></td>252<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">764 245</span></td>253<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">105 554</span></td>254<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">5 045 778</span></td>255<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">51 367</span></td>256<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:yellow;">170</span></td>257<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">10357874</span></td>258</tr>259</table>260</div>261</div>262<hr>263<div class="step">264<div class="step-title">Step 4: Use a `CASE` statement to return TRUE if the number of rows is equal to 1, otherwise return FALSE.</div>265<div id="step-2" class="content">266<table>267<tr>268<td>age_group</td>269<td>brazil_100___percent_of_the_population</td>270<td>white_47_73___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>271<td>black_7_61___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>272<td>yellow_1_09___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>273<td>brown__multiracial__43_13___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>274<td>indians_0_43___percent_in_the_race___percent_in_the_age_group</td>275<td>unspecified_0_0034</td>276<td>population_15_17</td>277</tr>278<tr>279<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">15 - 17</span></td>280<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">10 357 874</span></td>281<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">4 390 760</span></td>282<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">764 245</span></td>283<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">105 554</span></td>284<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">5 045 778</span></td>285<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">51 367</span></td>286<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">170</span></td>287<td><span class="highlighted-cell" title="Used in transformation" style="background-color:#90EE90;">10357874</span></td>288</tr>289</table>290</div>291</div>292<hr>293<div class="step">294<div class="step-title">Final output table:</div>295<div id="step-3" class="content">296<table>297<tr>298<td>verification_result</td>299</tr>300<tr>301<td>TRUE</td>302</tr>303</table>304</div>305</div>306<hr>307<div class="step"><h3><span class="true">Prediction: TRUE </span></h3>308<h3>Ground-truth:</span> TRUE</h3></div>309</body></html>310